Flash Movie Review: The Holdovers
ONE YEAR I WAS ENROLLED IN an overnight camp, and it turned out to be the only time I agreed to such a thing. It was fun to be with friends morning and night, though I was anxious about the bunkbeds. I was assigned to an upper bunk and desperately did not want it because of being overweight. Not that I was any type of extreme heaviness, but my little kid’s mind had blown it out of proportion. I remember slowly climbing the ladder one rung at a time, testing to make sure it would support me. The food served us was picked more for nourishment instead of taste, so I did not care for it. The thing that upset me the most were the organized activities like swimming and baseball. I knew how to play them, but I was never competitive; the counselors always turned them into a contest to see who was the “best.” I must tell you I was one of those “weird” kids who brought a book to read; there were not many others who did such a thing. Thinking about it and how today I live a very structured life; back then, it was the structure I was rebelling against. I did not like being told when I could eat or shower. By the end of the session, I could not wait to be back in my own home. OVERNIGHT/SUMMER CAMP WAS NOT THE only thing I disliked. I never cared for school field trips. It was not the destination so much, but the going and coming I truly could not stand. First, my good time was based on who was on my bus. If our bus had any troublemakers, then I knew for sure our ride to whatever place we were going would be hellish. It would always be worse if one of the troublemakers sat close to you because it was more than likely you would become one of their targets. Another reason I did not like the bus rides was because if someone happened, through the luck of the draw, to be sitting by themselves then the teacher or one of the chaperones would take up residency next to that lone student; or worse, have them join them at the front of the bus. It always stressed me out with kids shoving and pushing, singing ridiculous songs, the adults yelling and for what? Sometimes we did go to cool places but other times they were lame and boring. The way I feel about such things, if I found myself in a situation like the main characters in this comedic drama, I would have run away. STUCK WITH NOWHERE TO GO, A teacher, cook and student are stuck over the Christmas holiday break at their prep school. None of them want to be there. With Paul Giamatti (Jungle Cruise, Billions-TV) as Paul Hunham, Da’Vine Joy Randolph (The Lost City, Rustin) as Mary Lamb, newcomer Dominic Sessa as Angus Tully, Carrie Preston (True Blood-TV, They/Them) as Miss Lydia Crane and Brady Hepner (The Black Phone, Resisting Roots) as Teddy Kountze; this film was a joy to watch. The acting was wonderful, and the script was intelligent with its mix of humor, sadness and drama that kept me engaged with the story early on. I also thought the characters were well developed. There were not necessarily laugh out loud moments, but there were humorous spots that were appropriate for the story. What really made this film stand out was its adult storytelling and script. It was refreshing to sit back and watch a good story unfold without the special effects or brand marketing. The other thing that set this film apart were its details. For example, there actually was one special effect, but a good many viewers may not even be aware of it taking place. This picture is an Oscar contender and rightfully so.
3 ½ stars
Posted on January 24, 2024, in Dramedy and tagged 3 1/2 stars, carrie preston, comedy, da'vine joy randolph, drama, dramedy, history, new england, paul giamatti, prep school. Bookmark the permalink. 9 Comments.
Wow! This film was produced by people who live in my old hometown — I’m so glad you like it and that its doing so incredibly well. It does sound good — I’ll definitely see it sometime!
How crazy you have this connection to the film; thank you for letting us know. Now, we really would love to hear what you think of the film after you have seen it.
Will do! It sounds wonderful!
I was surprised by how much I engaged with and enjoyed this movie. I don’t think the trailers really did it justice. It’s a much more thoughtful and tonally varied piece than the trailer indicated. I thought the performances were superb and the writing was really skillful. While I don’t think it had anything startling to say on any topic, I think the quality of those two aspects of the filmmaking meant that it didn’t really matter.
Thanks for your thoughts Laura and I am glad you were surprised. I considered it a dark horseL little fanfare or buzz until the nominations came out.
Really good movie. I taught at a boarding school for 11 years and thought the characters were pretty representative of some of the students I taught. I liked the quiet pace of the movie.
Thank you so much for sharing your insight related to this film.
Fantastic review! I absolutely loved this film. I could connect to its message about the power of teachers having a positive impact on shaping students’ futures. As someone sharing a strong bond with my high school teacher, I related to its message. Here’s why I love the movie: https://huilahimovie.reviews/2023/11/29/the-holdovers-2023-movie-review/
Thank you again for telling us your thoughts.